On 21 January, the Institute for Development of Freedom of Information (IDFI) organized a discussion “Universal Healthcare Program – Assessing the Year 2015”. The discussion was held within the framework of the project “Strategic Plan Georgia 2020 – Strengthening Public Involvement”. The article was published on the blog.
Tengiz Verulava - Doctor of Medicine, Professor at Ilia State University and Zurab Tchiaberashvili – member of United National Movement (UNM) participated as speakers of the panel. Maia Maghlakelidze – Head of Universal Health Care Management Department of the Social Service Agency was also invited as a speaker of the panel. Unfortunately, despite the initial acceptance of the invitation, Ms. Maia did not attend the event.
Mr. Tchiaberashvili talked about the importance of access to information, which is crucial for assessing the healthcare program comprehensively. According to Mr. Tchiaberashvili, the National Healthcare Account (NHA) has not been published since 2013, which indicates the total expenditure on health as a percentage of the Gross Domestic Product (GDP) and the share of state expenditure in total expenditure on health. As highlighted by Tchiaberashvili, such information sheds light on the real situation in healthcare and is necessary to discern the reality. Additionally, the NHA can be used as a comparison tool with other countries and their respective healthcare systems. In order to assess the results of the universal healthcare program, information on geographic area of healthcare expenditures, reasons for the increase in consumption of healthcare services, as well as the situation in healthcare insurance beyond the universal healthcare program are required.
Tchiaberashvili also discussed statistic data of private expenditures on health and noted that in comparison with data from 2010, in 2014 the situation deteriorated for the most vulnerable and the poorest part of the society. According to the panelist, the situation is worse for those with chronic diseases – healthcare expenses for those with chronic diseases living in rural areas increased by 11% on average, as for the poorest part of the population – by 8%. Cost containment mechanisms and excessive spending were named as problematic areas in the healthcare system.
As recommendation, Tchiaberashvili proposed moderate and calculated increase in healthcare expenditures, as well as target-based approach towards healthcare.
While evaluating the results of universal healthcare program, Tengiz Verulava noted that despite the growth in state healthcare financing, Georgia still lags behind not only the threshold recommended by the WHO, but also the indicators of low-income, poor states. According to data from World Bank (WB), Georgia lags behind countries such as – Armenia, Kyrgyzstan and Belarus in terms of the share of state expenditure in total expenditure on health, share of state expenditure on health in total expenditure of the state and State expenditure on health as a percentage of the Gross Domestic Product (GDP).
Verulava also discussed the positive trends of the healthcare sector and noted that Hepatitis C treatment program and introduction of prescriptions were positive developments. Development of state-private partnership organizations on the healthcare market, increase in use of ambulatory medical institutions among the public, increase in state expenditure on healthcare and role of primary healthcare were also named as positive developments.
In terms of existing problems in the system, the panelist pointed out the increase in prices on drugs and medical services, lack of finances for drug acquisition (especially among the chronically diseased), insufficient development of primary healthcare, lack of involvement of private insurance companies, lack of use of cost-effectiveness analysis when choosing medical services to be included in the program, lack of quality and inexistence of cost-containment mechanisms. According to Verulava this is evident, as the rate of urgent surgical operations increased by 314% after the universal healthcare program was introduced.
While proposing recommendations, Verulava highlighted the importance of including drugs in the program, especially for chronically diseased. Development of different forms of ownership of medical organizations, as well as more involvement of private insurance companies were also named as priorities. The panelist also noted that patient co-financing of healthcare expenditures, use of cost-effectiveness analysis while choosing medical services and increasing the quality of medical services should be on the agenda.
The Summary of the Results of the Second Year of the Educational Certification Program in Fighting Corruption02.08.2021
COVID-19 and the Georgian Education Sector29.07.2021
Civil Society Organisations: Government Uses State Security Service as Mechanism of Total Control02.08.2021
Guðmundur Andri Ástráðsson v. Iceland: Breach of Domestic Law on Judicial Appointments Violated the Right to a Fair Trial10.02.2021
Were Georgians Beloved in the Soviet Union?23.11.2020